If you’ve asked for a quote to switch to a tankless water heater, you may have noticed it costs much more than putting in a new tank. You may wonder what that extra money pays for.
Much of the difference comes from changes your home may need, such as a larger gas line or new venting. If you pick the cheapest quote and it leaves out that work, the new heater may shut itself off or run short of hot water. Below, we’ve covered what tankless water heater installers in Cincinnati, OH, add to the job and how they size the unit for your home.
Key Highlights
- A tank water heater typically burns about 40,000 to 80,000 BTUs per hour, while a tankless unit can burn up to about 199,000 BTUs while it runs.
- Your gas line has to supply that peak demand along with your furnace and other gas appliances.
- Many tankless units need new plastic vent pipe, and condensing models also need a drain for the water they produce.
- A tankless unit delivers fewer gallons per minute when the incoming water is colder, so installers size it for winter.
Can a Tankless Heater Use Your Old Tank’s Gas Line?
Sometimes. A tankless heater only burns gas while hot water runs, but it burns it much faster than a tank. According to Contractor magazine, a typical tank heater uses about 40,000 to 80,000 BTUs per hour, while a tankless unit uses about 120,000 to 199,000 when it fires. A BTU is a measure of heat, so the higher number means the burner needs more gas at the same moment.
Your gas line has to carry enough gas for that peak, plus whatever else is running, such as your furnace. That can be a problem in an older home, because builders sized its gas piping for the appliances it had back then. The Ohio County Profile for Hamilton County puts the median year built at 1963. It also shows that about 61% of occupied homes heat with gas, so in many homes the furnace shares that supply.
Not every home needs a new gas line, though. Contractor magazine notes that some newer models can run on lower gas pressure than older tankless units. To find out, the installer checks the size of the gas pipe and how far it runs from the meter, then adds up what every gas appliance in the home uses.
What Other Work Does a Tankless Installation Need?
Besides the gas line, a tankless water heater installation usually includes these changes:
- New venting. Many tankless units vent through plastic pipe, so the installer usually can’t reuse the old tank’s metal flue and runs a new vent through a wall or the roof. Navien’s NPE-2 series, for example, uses 2-inch or 3-inch PVC vent pipe that can run up to 75 feet.
- A condensate drain. A condensing unit pulls so much heat from its exhaust that water condenses inside it. That water has to drain away, so the installer runs a line to a floor drain or adds a small pump. Many installers also add a neutralizer, since the water is mildly acidic.
- An electrical outlet. The unit’s controls and fan run on electricity. Navien’s NPE-2 units need a standard 120-volt supply.
- Service valves. Isolation valves on the water lines let a technician flush the unit later without cutting into the pipes.
Each of these adds time and parts, which is why a tankless quote costs more than a tank swap. When you compare quotes, check that each one lists the same work.
How Do Installers Size a Tankless Water Heater?
Installers size a tankless unit by its flow rate, the number of gallons of hot water it can deliver each minute. They work it out in a few steps:
- They check how much the water needs to warm up. Flow rate depends on the temperature rise, the number of degrees the unit has to heat the water. Water comes into your home colder in winter, so the rise is bigger then.
- They check the unit’s flow at that rise. Navien’s specifications for its NPE-240A2 show how much this matters. The unit delivers about 11.2 gallons per minute with a 35°F temperature rise, but only about 5.6 gallons per minute with a 67°F rise.
- They count the fixtures you use at once. The installer adds up what your household runs at the same time, such as two showers and a dishwasher.
- They size for the coldest days. The installer picks a unit that keeps up with that demand in winter. A unit sized for summer can leave you with lukewarm showers in January.
“Thinking about going tankless? At Eco Plumbers, our plumbers train continuously at Eco Plumbers University, and we give free estimates from our West Chester Township location. Ask about our Go Tankless special when you contact us or call 513-443-1169.”
FAQs
1. Can a tankless water heater run on a 1/2-inch gas line?
Sometimes, but it may be too small. Many tankless units, including Navien’s NPE-2 series, have a 3/4-inch gas connection. A 1/2-inch line can work when it’s short and few other gas appliances share it. The installer calculates the line size before deciding if it needs an upgrade.
2. Why does a tankless water heater sometimes give a burst of cold water?
When you turn the hot water off and back on quickly, the hot water left in the pipe comes out first. The unit then has to restart, so a few seconds of cold water follow before the new hot water arrives. It’s normal for tankless heaters and doesn’t mean anything is wrong.
3. Does a tankless water heater need a floor drain?
Only a condensing unit does, since it’s the type that produces condensate water. A non-condensing unit doesn’t need a drain, but it needs stainless steel vent pipe.
4. Can a tankless water heater go where the old tank was?
Usually, yes. Most units mount on a wall, so the installer can often use the same spot as long as the gas line and vent can reach it. Moving it may add cost, since the gas and water lines would need to move too.
5. Is an electric tankless water heater easier to install?
Not always. A whole-house electric tankless unit draws a lot of power, so it often needs several large circuits and sometimes a bigger electrical panel. In a home that already has gas, a gas unit is often the simpler choice.







